Browner V. American Trucking Associations

The Free essays given on our site were donated by anonymous users and should not be viewed as samples of our custom writing service. You are welcome to use them to inspire yourself for writing your own term paper. If you need a custom term paper related to the subject of Accounting or Browner V. American Trucking Associations, you can hire a professional writer here in just a few clicks.
The lower courts decision in this case is hereby overturned. We disagree with the court s non-delegation decision and agree with Judge Tatle s dissent. The EPA is has not been delegated too much power, but that Congress has given them guidelines to follow that may be broad but do not constitute a non-delegation issue. Section 109 requires that the EPA publish air quality standards the attainment and maintenance of which in the judgment of the Administrator, based on such criteria and allowing an adequate margin of safety, and requisite to protect the public health. First, as per Judge Tatel s examples of Supreme Court cases giving precedent sustaining general congressional delegations, he is correct. Three examples are: national Broadcasting Co. v. United States (1943). The Communication Act of 1934 gave the FCC authority to regulate broadcast licensing in the public interest . This is a broad delegation of power, in the public interest ; the FCC can interpret the public interest and decide what is best for the public. In Yakus v. United States (1944), the authority to fix fair and equitable commodities prices was given to the Price Administrator. Finally, FPC v. Hope Natural Gas Co. (1944), the Federal Power Commission was allowed to determine just and reasonable rates. These agencies decide what is in the public interest , what are fair and Equitable commodities prices, and what are just and reasonable rates. These are no different than requisite to protect the public health which is the mandate given the EPA. This is more specific than the others because they must set standards that protect the public health and disregard other considerations such as economic analysis, impact on businesses, etc. Congress creates Administrative Agencies because it is impossible for the Legislature to collect all the information and manage all the details to follow through with the statutes that they pass. Agencies are given these tasks to allow a more efficient government that will be able to do what is necessary according to statutes by the Legislature. Agencies must be given flexibility in which to do their jobs. They have discretion but at the same time are checked by Judicial Review and Congressional Oversight. Both have been used in this case because the Act has been under regular congressional oversight hearings in Congress and has been reviewed by the Courts at least 10 times and we have not found these problems to be present in the past. This court agrees with Judge Tatle on these points he makes. This is a broad delegation of power but not too broad. The EPA has been given a mandate and guidelines to follow to reach the goal of Congress. The EPA uses the Clean Air Act to guide them in their decision-making process on the standards they set. The EPA has given explanations for what they have done. In this case their explanation for setting the ozone level at .08ppm is rational according to their explanations. First, the affects below .08 are less than at higher levels and are transient and reversible . They can be fixed. Second, the set level should not be below the naturally occurring ozone level concentrations. Ozone background levels have been as low as .045 and as high as .075 (infrequently) from natural sources. The lower court s decision leads this court to believe that they would expect the EPA to make the level zero because then nothing will affect the public health. Setting this at zero is not an option here and is an overexertion of the lower courts ability. The EPA has given an explanation for what they have done, and it is justified. Even though they

Our inspirational collection of essays and research papers is available for free to our registered users

Related Essays on Accounting

Accounting Standars

Introducton As you requested, I have researched the many possible methods used to account for long-term assets, and prepared a statement outlining my recommendations. The conclusions outlined herei...

Accounting and Auditing Processes

Justin Denman Accounting and Auditing Processes March 4, 2000 Writing Assignment #1 Revenue Recognition Policies The purpose of this paper is to compare the revenue recognition p...

The Importance Of Accounting

The Importance Of Accounting In Our Modern Society Accounting is a very important term to our modern society. It is the career for men and women who at the start have their eyes set on top positio...

Accounting Ethics

Accounting Ethics When examining the effect of open marketing on the profession of accounting it is important to view it from three perspectives: the client's, the profession's, and society...

Efficient Market Hypothesis And The Cost Of Capital

The quote shows a strong relation to the efficient market hypothesis (EMH), as it implies that the costs of capital are dependent from the amount of information given by the company. According to m...

Ais Solutions

E-Commerce XAccounts Receivable The purpose of the accounts receivable program is to keep track and report on money owed to your company by your customers as a result of providing them with goods o...

www.kover-samolet.com.ua/kovry/vostochnye-kovry/

У нашей фирмы нужный web-сайт , он описывает в статьях про Куттер https://www.apach.com.ua/shop/category/elektromehanicheskoe-oborudovanie/kuttery
В интеренете нашел интересный интернет-сайт со статьями про Холодильный стол купить https://www.apach.com.ua/shop/category/holodilnoe-oborudovanie/stoly-holodilnye