Accounting/ Accounting Ethics term paper 17790

Accounting term papers
Disclaimer: Free essays on Accounting posted on this site were donated by anonymous users and are provided for informational use only. The free Accounting research paper (Accounting Ethics essay) presented on this page should not be viewed as a sample of our on-line writing service. If you need fresh and competent research / writing on Accounting, use the professional writing service offered by our company.
View / hide essay

Accounting Ethics

When examining the effect of open marketing on the

profession of

accounting it is important to view it from three

perspectives: the

client's, the profession's, and society's. Additionally,

two key areas

that are affected by marketing must be addressed,

these are concerning competition, and ethical implications.

Marketing in

public accounting is here to stay therefore making an

argument against its

existence would be fruitless; however, in order to achieve

maximum benefit

to the firm, the client, and s ociety more stringent

guidelines must be

implemented at the firm level.

The first, and most obvious, of the effected areas is


Within competition several points are discussed. First, the


advertising has on public accounting-- the model of perfect


versus the model of monopolistic compet ition. Secondly,

the relationship

between firm size and advertising expenditures. Thirdly,

the effect of

advertising on firm specialization, the implications of

client turnover on

public accounting practice.

Before making the comparison, a brief explanation why the


models are chosen is in order. Monopolistic competition has

been chosen

for the pre-advertising era because it most closely

resembles the market

structure in an extreme sense. The elements o f

monopolistic competition

are as follows: product differentiation, the presence of

large numbers of

sellers, and nonprice competition. Although accounting

services between

firms offer very little service differentiation, the absence


advertising serve s as a replacement because clients are not


aware that other options are easily attainable. The

post-advertising era

is explained through the model of perfect competition for

which the

qualifications are as follows: very little or no service d


many sellers, and price as the only means of distinguishing

one firms

service from anothers.

In a perfectly competitive market the price of a particular

service is established solely by the interaction of market

demand and

supply. (Thompson p.277) When market demand for accounting


increases the resulting demand shifts right causing pri ces

to increase

returning the market back to equilibrium. However when

supply increases,

such is the theoretical effect of adding advertisement to


accounting practice, the supply curve shifts right causing

prices to fall.

The model of monopolistic competition is also price


however only at the firm level. For example, the CPA firm

of XYZ has an

established clientele base and uses referrals as its sole

means of growth.

They increase prices only as their cost o f providing the


increases and therefore are able to maintain their client

base. In this

example a gently downsloping demand curve exists (Thompson

p.304) causing

only drastic changes in pricing to send their client base

shopping for a

new firm. The result is XYZ can continue to grow by

practicing fair

pricing and providing a reputable service. Cut rate pricing


marginally effects their client base because there is little

means to make

their pricing publicly known, and only drastic, unwarran ted


sends clients packing.

Conversely, in the post-advertising era, XYZ must always be


of market pricing because the demand curve is steeper and

more volatile.

Therefore the client base of XYZ is not stable as in the

previous example

and measures must be taken to keep price s competitive with

other firms

regardless of cost inferences. The result is the necessity

of a more

aggressive policy regarding new client recruiting and a

higher turnover of

existing clients.

Now that the differences are established, the resulting

issues in

public accounting can be discussed. The first area

deserving discussion

is the relationship between firm size and advertising.

expenditures. A

study made of CPA firms in Britain in 1985 asserted "the

most dramatic

contrast between advertisers and non-advertisers was their


(O'Donohoe p.122) The obvious reason for this anomaly is

availability of

resources. Larger firms ha ve, at their disposal, a much

larger profit

level; therefore advertising expense is easily included only


affecting bottom line. This implies larger firms to have

gained a great

deal more from inclusion of advertising than small firms.

Consequ ently,

small firms could be pushed out of the picture entirely in

the area of

audit services.

Why? In the area of audit services, small firms have

little to

offer to differentiate themselves from their larger

counterparts who can

now freely move in and perform the service at a lower price.


unfortunately, will be a byproduct of the adverti sing era.

Smaller firms

only hope is to emphasize "personalized service" in tax and

full service

areas in hope that audit services can result. The major

drawback is small

firms are offered little room for growth because of the

expense involved.

Adverti sing in public accounting causes perspective clients

to become

bottom line oriented meaning the firms with the most

available revenue to

dump into advertising, coupled with the resources to offer

lowest fees are

the ones which grow. These resources are h eld by Big Six

firms and large

regional firms. As a result these firms will grow while

small firms


The second inference drawn from the model of perfect


is some smaller firms being forced to specialize. In order


differentiate themselves some smaller regionally operated

firms have

chosen to specialize. In the March 1990 issue of the CPA

Journal Arvid Mostad, CPA published an article in which he

set up "Seven

Marketing Guidelines." His first guideline was "Create your

own special

niche." (Mostad p.54) He goes on to encourage small firms to

establish an

area of expertise. (Mostad p.54)

This develops significant implications regarding firm

longevity in a

capitalistic market of industry upswings and downturns. An

example of

this is the construction industry in the

Baltimore-Washington corridor.

The industry experienced phenomenal growt h in the Eighties

followed by a

near halt. The result? many small to medium size firms

following the

advice of specialization went belly up along with their

clients. This

uncertainty exists with any firms who specialize. !

Firm specialization clearly is n

The final implication of the new competitive market is


turnover. Gone are the days when firms could guarantee

retaining a client

by providing a quality service at a fair price. New market


require firms to constantly evaluate pricing st rategies,

and, in some

cases bid on jobs yearly. This creates high levels of

client turnover.

The result is firms must always actively seek new clients.


drawbacks of this are increased overhead costs to firms,

less stability,

and greater servic e cost. Firms overhead costs increase

because the

expenses of replacing clients must be absorbed. This

expense comes from

both marketing tools used to attract clients, and costs of

preparing a bid

to perform a service. Firms which previously served a

client base from

year to year must face the uncertainty of retention of their

client base

now. The cost of providing a service to a new client

greatly exceeds that

of providing the same service to an existing client. When !

providing a service to a new clie

Now that the difference in the competition aspect of public

accounting is established emphasis is changed to examine the


implications derived as a result. In the area of ethics one

must examine

differences in independence, and integrity, and eva luate

the changes in

quality of service resulting from these areas.

When examining independence one must maintain an emphasis

on the

competitive structure of the market and new pressures in the

area of

client retention. Independence, one may argue, never

existed before;

however an assumption is made that independence, t o some


historically exists. With the competitive structure now

present the

process of gaining a new, and retaining an existing, client

has become

increasingly costly and time consuming. One may then infer

that once a

client is obtained, a firm would wish to do business with

that client for

an extended number of years, in order to realize the benefit

of expenses

incurred. Put simply, a firm would not look kindly toward a

partner who

lost a new client. This, inherently, decreases auditor

indep endence

during the first several years of the engagement. The

partner overseeing

the audit must always concern himself with the consequences

of losing the

engagement. Previously, firms worked mostly with

longstanding clien!

ts and the relationship developed

The second major area of ethical effect is that of


Competition has resulted in some firms damaging the

integrity of the

profession. This damage has occurred mainly through pricing


Two deviant practices have become commonplace in today's

market. These

are below cost pricing, and discount pricing. Many firms

have adopted

policies of below cost pricing as a tool of market


(Formichella p.199) implications regarding the motives and

integrity of

these firms must be explo red. Is it reasonable to assume

that a firm

would be willing to absorb a loss from an engagement, or

would a more

practical assumption state that firms which lowball would

seek means to

cut service costs at the expense of quality? It is not

possible to answer

this question; however its mere existence creates a damaging

effect on the

integrity, or at least perceived integrity, of the


The second pricing strategy which is cut-rate pricing


similar questions. In his commentary Mario Formichella

states the


It is no longer unusual to find firms willing to

take on work at substantial discounts from


fee levels. While there may be justifications for

performing services at reduced rates during


periods in special situations such as for


institutions or similar organizations, the extent


which this practice has grown cannot be justified

on any logical or professional basis. (Formichella

p. 81)

The distaste shown by Mr. Formichella in the area of

cut-rate pricing

shows it as an issue of concern and one which damages

integrity. Mr.

Formichella goes on to call for the implementation of


standards to prohibit actions such as this which

are damaging to the image and integrity of the profession.

One would

have to agree with his statement; however difficulties

arise, in the area

of monopolistic activity when guidelines are established

regarding pricing

strategies across an industry. Unf ortunately the

profession must rely on

the integrity of individual firms to guard against this

strategy. As a

result, this is a practice likely to continue, albeit

damaging to the

profession and those which rely on the statements made by

the profession.

The existence of advertising in public accounting creates a


environment to which firms are still adapting. This new

environment is

largely the result of increased competition and a clientele

which is

increasingly more bottom line oriented. In order

to compete firms must place more emphasis on marketing and

accept it as a

cost of doing business. The result of this will be more


penetration and an increasingly limited number of small

firms in the

business. Market pressures also are forcing

creating situations where ethical issues such as

independence and

integrity are questioned making it imperative that the AICPA


guidelines from which the evolving profession must base

itself. In the

age of deregulation accounting jumped on the boa t, now it

is becomin


Live support is now available round-the-clock 24/7
A paper writing site You CAN trust!
  • 10+ years of experience in paper writing
  • Any assignment on any level. Any deadline!
  • Open 24/7 Your essay will be done on time!
  • 200+ essay writers. Live Chat. Great support
  • No Plagiarism. Satisfaction. Confidentiality.