The Controversial Issue Of Animal Ethics

The Free essays given on our site were donated by anonymous users and should not be viewed as samples of our custom writing service. You are welcome to use them to inspire yourself for writing your own term paper. If you need a custom term paper related to the subject of Animal Testing or The Controversial Issue Of Animal Ethics , you can hire a professional writer here in just a few clicks.
The Controversial Issue of Animal Ethics The struggle against sickness and disease is not over, yet medical progress is being threatened by activists who would end the use of laboratory animals in the search for treatment and cures. Their well financed anti-research disinformation campaign is not the only weapon used by animal rights activists. The more extreme animal rights activists have used tactics of intimidation and terrorism, for example: April 26,1997, activists were arrested when they tried to force their way into Yerkes Regional Primate center during a protest. July 21,1997, The Animal Liberation Front (ALF) set fire to Cavel West, a horse rendering plan. July 5,1998, The ALF broke into a laboratory at Cornell University and released dozens of woodchucks into the wild. (Americans for Medical Progress 2) These are only a few examples of intimidation and terrorism that activists use to get their point across. The animals used in those labs were all for ideal laboratory animal research. They were not being used for cosmetic studies. They were strictly being used for medical purposes. Some things that they were in research for were to study liver cancer, hepatitis, and to get tissues to treat skull born birth defects in children. In order to decide whether these actions taken by activists are right or appropriate we need to answer this question: Are the benefits of animal experimentation worth the pain that the laboratory animal experiences? Once this question is answered, the question of whether animal Secor 2 experimentation is ethical or not will also be answered. The use of animals in the life sciences goes back to ancient Greece and the earliest medical experiments. To learn about swallowing, ancient physicians cut open the throat of a living pig. To study the heart they cut into its chest. For centuries, physicians and researchers used animals to enhance their knowledge about how the various organs and systems of the body functioned, as well as to improve their surgical skills. As this knowledge grew, new scientific disciplines were born. First physiology, and pharmacology, and much later bacteriology, and immunology evolved as animal experimentation became more widespread. Table 2 depicts the great leaps animal experimentation has provided to the human race. This timeline is proof of great advances gained from animal testing for human benefit. Without testing or experimentation of animals none of this would have evolved. Human beings are not the only species who benefit from animal testing. Table 1 depicts the advances in biomedical research for animals. Without animal research humans and animals would still be dying or totally wiped out from these diseases. Advances for Animals Table 1 Vaccines: Rabies Distemper Canine Parvo Virus Feline Respiratory disease Feline Leukemia Anthrax Tetanus Hepatitis Nutrition: Heart disease in cats was eliminated supplementing diets with Taurine. This also prevented Feline Urologic Syndrome (FUS) Heartworm: A rapid and accurate test now facilitates diagnosis of this insect-transmitted disease. Heartworm medication, also discovered through animal experimentation is one of the most important advances in the history Lime Disease: Spread by ticks, this disease causes arthritis as well as heart and Kidney problems in dogs. Animal research led to a vaccine to prevent infection, as well as more accurate diagnostic techniques. Endangered Species: Many endangered species have a chance of surviving thanks to biomedical research on in vitro fertilization and embryo transplant techniques. Source: Partners in Research. “Animals Benefit From Biomedical Research.” (15, Feb. 2000). Secor 3 Table 1 Advances in Medicine Through Animal Research Pre 1900’s Treatment for Smallpox: Treatment for Whooping Cough: One of the worlds most dreaded A highly communicable respiratory disease plagues, estimated to have caused characterized by short, dry coughs. Species two million deaths. Species studied: cows studies: guinea pigs and rabbits Treatment for Anthrax: 1950’s Disease marked by rise in body temperature, Prevention of Polio: followed by depression, spasms respiratory or A disease marked by symptoms ranging from mild cardiac distress, convulsions, and death. infection to extensive paralysis. Today the disease has Species studied: sheep been eradicated in the western hemisphere. Species 1900’s studied: rabbits, monkeys, and rodents Cardiac Catheterization Techniques: Discovery of DNA A procedure which allows doctors to Determines individual hereditary characteristics. insert a flexible tube into an artery or vein Species studied: rats and mice to the heart, used for injecting drugs directly Development of Open Heart Surgery and into the heart to measure blood flow and Cardiac Pacemaker: pressure, diagnose and treat congenital Revolutionized treatment for people suffering from heart disease and narrowed passages. sever heart disease. Species studies: dogs Species studied: dogs, rabbits Development of Cancer Chemotherapy: 1920’s Can bring about remission of certain cancers, either Discovery of Insulin: short-term or permanently. Species studied: monkeys To control diabetes, a chronic disease of the rabbits, and rodents pancreas marked by the inability to utilize 1960’s carbohydrates, excess sugar in the blood and Prevention of Rubella: urine, excessive thirst, hunger and urination, An epidemic viral disease marked by low fever, rash, weakness and emaciation. Species studies: dogs enlarged lymph glands; can cause fetal defects in 1940’s pregnant women. Species studied: monkeys Prevention of Diphtheria: 1970’s An acute contagious disease marked by Prevention of Measles: formation of membranes in the throat and An acute contagious viral disease, once common in other air passages. childhood, marked by fever and skin eruptions. Can Species studied: horses cause death. Species studied: monkeys Antibiotics: 1990’s Development of penicillin and other antibiotics Breast cancer links: revolutionized the treatment of bacterial infection Scientists are closing in on the genetic and in humans and other animal. Species studies: environmental factors of breast cancer, which is the many including rats, mice and rabbits leading cause of death of American women ages 35-54. Species studied: fruitflies, mice, and rats Source: Americans for Medical Progress Educational Foundation. “Advances in Medicine Through Animal Research.” (7, Feb. 2000). There are many great advantages of animal experimentation. But over the years animals have been tortured. In order to prevent animal cruelty many laws and regulations have been passed. Some of the main ones are that unnecessary duplication of research. Replication of experiments may be reasonable, but the investigator must provide sufficient information to justify why an experiment needs to be repeated. The number of animals should be the minimum necessary to produce valid results and the investigator must clearly present the method where the number of requested animals was calculated. Lastly when its appropriate a non-animal substitute should be used, or a species of lower order. Secor 4 Animal experimentation has taken place since before the 1900’s. As proven in the two previous tables there have been many advances in medicine due to animal research. Although along the way there have been draw backs. Misleading results derived from animal experiments have delayed important medical advances. A study was done to find compounds that would reduce damage from ischemic stroke. There were 25 compounds that were proven to work on laboratory animals, yet none proved efficacious on human trials (Animal Research is Wastefull and Misleading 2). Scientists believe that this is because the stroke was suddenly given to the animals. So they did not undergo the slowly progressive arterial damage that usually plays a role in human strokes. The fight against poliomyelits (polio) was delayed due to misconceptions in studies done on monkeys. The experiments done on the monkeys indicated that the virus mainly infects the nervous system. When trials were done on humans they found that the gastrointestinal system was the primary route of infection. The reason the primary route was different was because the viral strains they had administered through the nose had artificially developed an affinity for brain tissue. This resulted in misguided preventive measures and it delayed the development of a vaccine. In addition medical research is used in laboratories to test the safety of drugs and other chemicals. The US Food and Drug Administration approved many substances that appeared to be safe in animal studies. When later used on humans they were found to be dangerous to the health of humans. A few examples of these drugs are milrinone, which increases cardiac output. While this drug raised the survival of rats with heart failure, humans on this drug had a 30% increase in mortality. The antiviral drug fialuridine was safe in animal trials, yet it caused liver failure in humans. The antidepressent nomifensine had minimal toxicity in lab animals, but caused liver toxicity and anemia in humans. Although there have been some set backs, there have also been many great advancements in medicine which relied heavily on animal experimentation. A prime example of this is the Secor 5 polio vaccine. Albert Sabin studied this virus and introduced his oral vaccine to the US in 1961. Polio was a very deadly disease. This epidemic condemned millions of children and young adults. In 1952, 58,000 children were struck down alone (Sabin 1). Without animal research Sabin would not have had enough knowledge to invent this vaccine, and without this vaccine polio would still be claiming thousands of lives each year. The antibiotic penicillin is another example of an advancement that came due to animal experimentation. In the 1940’s Howard W. Florey and Ernst B. Chain showed penicillin to be dramatically effective as an antibiotic by the mouse protection test. Without this test the this important antibiotic may never have been passed for human use. Another huge drug that is used in the everyday lives of many hunams is insulin. Before insulin was introduced to humans, people with diabetes typically died. Once the lifesaving drug was tested on rabbits and mice, humans were able to use it and live with the disease. The number of animals used in the US per year is outrageous (see table 3). Although the overall numbers have reduced in the in the past 22 years. This could be due to the new laws and regulations that are constantly being passed, or to the onset of alternatives. Source: Scientific American. The Numbers of Research Animals. http.// (16, Feb. 2000). As stated many times, animal experimentation has led to great advances in medicine, but there are other ways to make great leaps in medicine then testing these chemicals on thousands Secor 6 of animals. The most known alternatives are known as the three R’s. They are refinement, reduction, and replacement. These three alternatives provide a way to minimize animal use and suffering. Yet doing this without compromising the quality of the scientific work being done. While having the ultimate goal always being to totally replace animal models. Refinement is one of the stepping stones that will help reach the ultimate goal. This is the modification of any procedures that operate from the time a animal is born until its death. This is to minimize the pain and distress experienced by the animal, and also to improve its well-being. The experience of pain and other stress is likely to result in changes in the animal which has potential to raise the variability of experimental results. With that in mind it is in the best interest of scientists to ensure that the conditions in the animal house are the best possible. Minimizing the pain and distress the animal goes through, yields better results. When the experiment is over, the most humane method of euthanasia should be chosen also. The next stepping stone is reduction. This is any strategy that will result in a decreased amount of animals being used to obtain the same amount of data. Making the appropriate design and analysis of the experiment can increase the percision of the data and also enable fewer animals to be used. Doing a small pilot study could also indicate whether or not it is appropriate to go into a major study. This would eliminate huge studies that yield bad or useless results. The last stepping stone of the three R’s is replacement. A replacement is considered a experiment that does not entail the use of a whole, living animal. Replacement methods can be used to totally eliminate animals in a study, or they will complement animal experiments. Which would reduce the overall number of animals in the project. Common replacements are computer based systems, lower organisms, and cell culture systems. The three R’s are great stepping stones to totally eradicate animals in experimentation’s. Although chimpanzee’s DNA is that best match to human DNA. So it could be wise to study and experiment on these primates. Our closest evolutionary cousins are chimpanzees. Humans and chimps share 98% of our DNA (Cramer 1). The difference between the DNA of a human and the Secor 7 DNA of a chimp can fluctuate from 99.6% to 98%. Another interesting fact about the similarities in man and chimp is the difference between human and chimp is only 160 enzymes (Cramer 1). With this closeness in DNA we are able to see what will potentially happen

Our inspirational collection of essays and research papers is available for free to our registered users

Related Essays on Animal Testing

Animal Testing

Anderson 1 A Look at Animal Testing They're Pinky and the Brain, They're Pinky and the Brain, One is a genius; the other's insane, they're laboratory mice, Their genes have been spliced, They're P...

The Cruelty Of Animal Testing

During the seventies, Americans fought against animal cruelty. Animal cruelty is still a major problem in today's society. For many years we have been watching advertisements on television, then go...

The Animal Kingdom

Animals have their own beautiful world, free of complicating human theories. They don’t get into arguments, they don’t cheat, they don’t have heart breaks, they don’t follow any religion and ...

узнать больше

Наш нужный web-сайт про направление Профессиональный блендер