Defining A Mental Disorder

The Free essays given on our site were donated by anonymous users and should not be viewed as samples of our custom writing service. You are welcome to use them to inspire yourself for writing your own term paper. If you need a custom term paper related to the subject of Psychoanalysis or Defining A Mental Disorder, you can hire a professional writer here in just a few clicks.
The definition of the concept of a mental disorder, fundamental to the mental health field, has been an important and controversial issue in psychology. Labeling a person s behavior abnormal, effects the way they are viewed and view themselves, and determines the recommendations for treatment. Since the term describes such a broad range of illnesses, it is difficult to come up with a definition that is adequately inclusive and consistent. J.C. Wakefield (1992) made a compelling argument that defined a mental disorder as a harmful dysfunction. However, the fourth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (as cited in Emery & Oltmanns, 1998) provides a more complete definition that includes the different characteristics of mental disorders, while excluding certain conditions that could lead to behavior that may be misconstrued as evidence of a mental disorder. Specifically, the DSM IV (as cited in Emery & Oltmanns, 1998) requires that present distress, disability, or a significantly increased risk of suffering death, pain, disability, or an important loss of freedom must characterize a behavioral or psychological syndrome for it to be a mental disorder. Present distress refers to physically or psychologically painful symptoms experienced by a person. Together, the increased risk and present distress characteristics roughly correspond to Wakefield s belief that mental disorders must be conditions that cause harm to an afflicted person (Wakefield, 1992). This harm might be in adjustment (such as ruining interpersonal relationships), mental distress (such as anxiety or depression), or physical effects (such as suicide, or other bodily harm). Likewise, disability, referring to the impairment in one or more important areas or functioning, corresponds to Wakefield s belief that conditions must also result from the inability of some mental mechanism to perform its natural function (Wakefield, 1992). However, the DSM-IV (as cited in Emery & Oltmanns, 1998) requires that a syndrome must not be merely an expectable and culturally sanctioned response to a particular event, deviant behavior, or a conflict between the individual and society. Likewise, Wakefield believed that harmfulness should be judged by the standards of a person s culture, but lacks specifications for that critical judgement. Along with A. Kleinman (1988), he criticized the inadequate consideration of cultural differences in the DSM s previous editions. These conditions for exclusion are essential in accounting for differences in what is considered normal behavior cross-culturally, and indicate the difficulty in deciding whether the behavior of a person in another culture is indicative of a mental disorder. The importance of the DSM-IV s exclusion criteria can be illustrated by comparing anorexia nervosa, a condition that is a mental disorder by the DSM-IV s definition, to religious fasting, a condition that is not considered to be a mental disorder. Anorexia nervosa is a mental disorder characterized by extreme emaciation, a disturbed perception of (one s own) body, an intense fear of gaining weight, and the cessation of menstruation (in women) (Emery & Oltmanns, 1998). This condition is included as a mental disorder by the DSM-IV s definition by all three defining characteristics. The fear of weight gain and obsessive thoughts related to body image indicate present distress. The stopping of menstruation attests to impairment in reproductive functioning, and the extremely low body weight increases the risk of suffering death or disability (such as osteoporosis). Since anorexia is not merely an expected response to any event, deviant behavior of a minority group, or a conflict between the individual and society, it is a mental disorder. In contrast, certain religions are known to fast, choosing not to eat for specified periods of time, in connection with their religious beliefs. Observation of a person displaying this behavior, without an under

Our inspirational collection of essays and research papers is available for free to our registered users

Related Essays on Psychoanalysis

Adult Deviance And Conduct Disorder

Running Head: ADULT DEVIANCE AND CONDUCT DISORDER The Relationship Between Childhood Deviance and Adult Deviance William T. Mahan II Neumann College Psych 301: Research Methods I Novembe...

History Of Boot Camp Corrections

History of Boot Camp Corrections In the military boot camp represents an abrupt, often shocking transition to a new way of life. Discipline is strict and there is an emphasis on hard work, physical...

Psychological Stress

Psychological stress Psychological stress is a result of many factors and should be dealt with very carefully. Stress can be defined as a set of interactions between the person and the environmen...


Psychological stress is a result of many factors and should be dealt with very carefully. Stress can be defined as a set of interactions between the person and the environment that result in ...

Motivation And Productivity Related To Job Satisfaction

Abstract The relationship between job satisfaction, motivation, and efficiency or productivity is very important in the business industry as well as in personal life. Long term research has ...


Depression Every person in the world today endures some kind of a hardship. Every misfortune is different; one person's could take the form of divorce while another's takes the form of a f...

build website

написание текстов

раскрутка сайта харьков